CKB Solutions
  • Home
  • Meet CKB
    • Greg Kovacic, CFA
  • Expertise & Experience
  • Case Studies
    • Corporate Finance
    • Doing Business in China
    • Market & Feasibility Studies
    • Marketing Communications
    • Operations & Organization
    • Strategy & Execution
  • Insights
    • 'Do' Diligence
    • Asia Marcoms M&A3
  • CKBlog
  • Contact Us
  • 中文
    • 关于CKB
    • CKB介绍 >
      • Greg Kovacic, CFA 简历
    • 专业知识与经验
    • 客户案例
    • 联系CKB

Poorly conceived government programs will always attract abuse and fraud

2/19/2013

 
Picture
When government money is involved, the potential for abuse and fraud is ever present.  There will always be people who will always look for ways to scam the system.  Waste and fraud quickly becomes a problem.  

The federal program is question is the LIfeline program which subsidizes wireless phone service to ensure poor people have the ability to call their families, jobs or for emergency help.

Until 2012, the FCC allowed consumers to self-certify their eligibility, and in many states documentation was not required.  Very poor idea.

Not surprisingly, A Wall Street Journal review of FCC data showed >40% of the 6 million subscribers at 5 of the program's top carriers were either ineligible or failed to show that they qualified.

Investigators have discovered questionable tactics by companies participating in the program.  For example: 
  • Signing up customers in hospital rooms
  • Enrolling subscribers by mailing them unsolicited phones
  • Signing up ineligible customers
  • Signing up the same customers multiple times
  • Signing up children
  • Applications lacking required signatures

Clues something was amiss:
  • In 2012, the government spent US$2.2 billion on the Lifeline program, up from $819 million 4 years earlier, as dozens of small companies were authorized to start providing the service.
  • Oklahoma experienced subscribers growing so fast the state is likely to exhaust the supply of phone numbers in the 405 area code sooner than expected.
  • Carriers signing up so many subscribers, more than mathematically possible.
  • A spike in Lifeline payments to specific carriers.  One in  Wisconsin went from receiving 1% of Lifeline reimbursements in the state in Q2 2010 to 33% of disbursements in Q2 2011.

Detecting and monitoring such waste and fraud becomes expensive and time consuming - a further waste of taxpayer money and government resouces.  Which raises the question: Should governments even get involved in this in the first place or are taxpayers and intended beneficiaries better off by an alternative arrangement?

Source: "Abuse Worries Grow on Phone Aid for Poor", Wall Street Journal, February 18, 2013.
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887323764804578312574084396946.html?mod=WSJ_hp_LEFTWhatsNewsCollection

CKB Solutions is all about real solutions for the real world.  To learn how we can help your business, contact Greg Kovacic in Hong Kong.



Comments are closed.

    Author

    Greg Kovacic is a Director with CKB Solutions in Hong Kong. He advises senior executives and entrepreneurs on strategy, corporate finance, operations and marketing with a focus on crafting real solutions for the real world.  
    You can contact Greg at: greg@ckbsolutions.com

    View my profile on LinkedIn

    Categories

    All
    Accounting Shenanigans
    Bad Marketing 101
    Brand Building 101
    Bright Ideas
    China Business
    China Business
    China Facade
    China Food Scandal
    Continuous Improvement
    Corporate Finance
    Digital
    "Do" Diligence
    Economics
    Emerging Market Business
    India Business
    Indonesia Business
    Industry: Airlines
    Industry: Appliances
    Industry: Auto
    Industry: FMCG
    Industry: Food
    Industry: Healthcare
    Industry: Hotels & Hospitality
    Industry: Insurance
    Industry: Mobile Games
    Industry: QSR
    Industry: Retail
    Industry: Smartphones
    Industry: Toys
    International Expansion
    Marketing
    Other
    Smart Social Business
    Strategy
    Waste Of Taxpayer Money

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.